Skin, Deep
Merle Kessler

09 April 2005

There is a website called OnHDTV.tv that claims it “provides show reviews and previews, HDTV-specific viewing recommendations, HDTV news and HDTV shopping tips, among other consumer information.”

我想这是世界现在需要的。

One of the services OnHDTV offered this past month was, of course, a list - and where would the internet be without lists? - the “ top 10 celebrities who look even better in High-Definition TV,” accompanied by a list of those who look worse.

Topping the “best” list was tennis star Anna Kournikova: “Her skin is glistening and luscious. It's easy to see why her matches sell out despite her limited talents. It's not love-15; it's love Anna.”

(当我读到这样一个句子的时候,我总是试着想象作家在工作时的样子,它试图从它的主题的某个熟悉的方面强加一个玩笑式的比喻,这是很痛苦的。我想知道他或她拒绝了哪些句子?无论是在球场上,还是在高清电视上,安娜每次都能拿高分。”“优势,安娜!” “It’s a close-up grand slam for Anna.”)

Angelina Jolie is also on the list. After describing her as “breathtaking,” the writer then issues a caveat: “The only negative: The actress has a small mole on her forehead. In high-def, it looks like Mt. Everest.”

So one of HDTV's pleasures, apparently, is givng the viewer the ability to pore over the pores of the rich and famous. And if you’re a critic watching, you get to praise the beautiful and sneer at them simultaneously.

Then there’s the other list.

On HDTV, Carmen Diaz “looks more like a Charlie than an angel.” Britney Spears: “The pop tart is still in her early 20s, but she looks about 10 years older in high-def.” William Devane, “who once played John F.Kennedy in a docudrama about the Cuban Missile Crisis, should duck and cover the next time they ask him to star in a HDTV program.” Jamie Lee Curtis? “Christopher Guest, be my guest. Buy your wife some Botox! And, a wig!” And, of course, Joan Rivers. “Do you remember that song, ‘Old Man River?’ Well, how about, ‘Old Woman Rivers?’”

Clearly, the author’s inventiveness started to flag by the end. Rhyming “Guest” with “guest” is not worth the punch in the nose Mr. Guest may give the writer should the two ever meet. As for the “Old Woman Rivers” crack, well, it does reach new depths of witlessness, I suppose. But this achievement is cancelled out, in my opinion, by its tin-eared clunkiness.

我自己从来都不太明白这类榜单的吸引力,我当然也不相信一个名人的光彩照或不光彩照会成为你花1500到4000美元买一台高清电视的一个因素。

但还有一个更大的谜团:如果这只是一场推广高清电视的运动,它是否显得非常恶意?这就是我们过去常常在别人背后说的那种尖酸刻薄的话。现在我们对便宜的座位大肆谩骂。就好像我们的电影明星身体上的缺陷预示着某种道德上的失败。

也许多亏了互联网、宽带和HTDV,我们已经相信电影明星真的可以和我们进行身体上的互动,如果我们足够刻薄,他们就会听从我们的命令。刮掉你的痘痘疤痕,你个贱人!离我的电视远点,老家伙!

And someday, if we wish hard enough, and if our sarcasm is polished enough, we will be able to examine our stars subcutaneously, scrubbing and mocking until every last one of them is blemish-free, even on a subatomic level.

Then, finally our viewing pleasure will be as perfect as we are. We will all be locked together, gazers and gazed, in the darkened living room, forever.

Comments(4)


Jason's picture

Jason

Thursday, June 16, 2005 -- 5:00 PM

I am the host of the Philosophical Question of the

我是每日哲学问题(PQD)博客的主持人,在这里我们提出的问题可能会吸引你。Please consider visiting the blog athttp://pqd.negativespace.com订阅PQD博客警报,这样当新的PQD发布时,你就可以得到通知。Just e-mail me atpqd@negativespace.com附上您希望警报发送到的电子邮件地址。同时,请鼓励您的朋友和同事加入我们的PQD博客,这是一个自由表达的免费博客。

Guest's picture

Guest

Sunday, July 17, 2005 -- 5:00 PM

Which is more important physical beauty or mental

Which is more important physical beauty or mental beauty? In Plato?s Symposium Alcibiades falls before Socrates in tears. He is enraged that Socrates does not love him for his physical beauty, the way he loves Socrates for his mental beauty. Socrates declares that it would be wrong for him to trade his mental beauty (gold) for mere physical beauty (brass).
这个故事是关于美的真相还是胡说八道?从整体上看,生理美和心理美哪个更受人类的重视?哪种美需要更多的力量、尊重和回报?如果外表美比外表美更受喜爱,是不是?
For many years I have agreed with Plato and held to the belief that physical beauty is lower than mental beauty. This idea also holds that physical beauty is admired by the majority of the human race, but that the majority of the human race does not have appreciation for higher forms of beauty such as courage/honor and reason/wisdom. But I have decided to attempt to push out all previous long held to memes about beauty and examine the whole topic anew.
What I have found is startling although it would not be accepted by philosophers who hold onto ancient beliefs about how beauty should be loved. What I have found is that physical beauty commands more power, respect, and love than mental beauty. For each unit of physical beauty there is more reward than for each unit of mental beauty.
我还发现,每个人最终渴望的其实不是精神之美,而是身体之美。人们一直教育他们的后代,外在的美并不重要,重要的是内在的美,但这当然是一个谎言。无论你是在求职,还是想吸引异性,外表的美比精神上的美更重要。如果我认为欣赏和获得外在美比精神美更与生存有关。
What I also argue is that each unit of physical beauty brings more reward than each unit of mental beauty. Certainly we have been taught to admire the mental over the physical, but we know this is a lie. I am not arguing that mental beauty should not be admired, but that the acquisition and appreciation of physical beauty should be admired at the same level or even more than mental beauty-basically that Plato was wrong in assigning physical beauty a lower status than mental beauty. That the scholar should not look down on physical beauty, or state that they want nothing to do with it. One main reason is the power that physical beauty commands. Most physical beauty does not come natural it takes hard work, but I argue that the rewards for each unit of physical beauty are more than each unit of mental beauty.
I also argue that Plato was wrong or that he was lying to the reader. It was another noble lie. The admiration of the physical human form was not looked down at during Greek antiquity.

Guest's picture

Guest

Thursday, September 8, 2005 -- 5:00 PM

Physical beauty rarely comes naturaly. It takes on

Physical beauty rarely comes naturaly. It takes one a lot of time and money to groom skin.

Guest's picture

Guest

Sunday, March 12, 2006 -- 4:00 PM

It's good to have a balance in physical beauty and

在身体美和精神美之间保持平衡是件好事。